FAIR JOURNAL
Receive our free monthly e-mail newsletter for defenders of the restored Gospel of Jesus Christ. You can unsubscribe at any time.
E-mail:

FAIR HOT SPOTS
FAIR Blog
Thoughts and commentary from the apologetic frontlines.
Polygamy Resources
Questions about polygamy and the Mormons? Find your answers here.
Bible vs. the Book of Mormon
A common-sense review of the anti-Mormon video from Living Hope Ministries.
The Truth About "The God Makers"
Classic, line-by-line examination of this anti-Mormon film and book.
DNA and the Book of Mormon
Does DNA evidence disprove the Book of Mormon?
Mormons and Masonry
How did Freemasonry figure into the early development of the Church.

 

IV. Edited Quotations That Change the Original Intent

The authors use over six hundred footnote references. It would be difficult for the reader to check these out since the references come from many sources. I did check out virtually every reference in The God Makers and found that many quotations as well as scriptures had been edited or taken out of context, and different meanings resulted. Here are a few examples:

What the book says

What the book omits or adds

1. "Joseph Smith [said], ‘I intend to lay a foundation that will revolutionize the whole world' " (209:33).

Two lines later the LDS prophet added, "It will not be by sword or gun that this kingdom will roll on."

2. Brigham Young is quoted praising Joseph Smith to show Latter-day Saints do not testify of Christ (41:4).

Much of the unquoted portion of the talk did praise Jesus Christ.

3. Heber C. Kimball urged saints to follow their leaders "whether it's right or wrong" (43:16).

His words just prior were, "\ may be wrong on this point." Heber C. Kimball was talking during a state of emergency in 1857, with federal troops poised to invade Salt Lake City.

4. Spencer W. Kimball said, "All transgressions must be cleansed {by temple rituals and good deeds] . . . " (179:7).

The words in brackets were added in the book and were not implied or stated in any way in the talk. (A person has to be cleansed before participating in the ritual.)

5. "Mormon writer William E. Berrett admits that a secret society called the 'Danites' . . .was organized within the Mormon Church 'for the purpose of plundering and murdering the enemies of the saints' " (224:35).

The same source also said "that Joseph Smith had nothing to do with [the Danites] and exposed the participants when he became aware of it, is equally well confirmed."

6. "Leland Gentry, also a Mormon, adds that the 'Danites were apparently taught to obey the commands of their superiors without question or hesitation' " (225:1-5).

The Gentry account also makes clear that not until the pre-trial hearing were Joseph Smith and his brethren made aware what members of this group had done and that the Danites tried to shift the responsibility for their crimes to Joseph Smith to save themselves.

7. Brigham Young said, the Christian God is the Mormon's devil (245, last).

President Young was quoting a person who once pointed out that to some Christians, both God and the devil were "without body." (It is not LDS doctrine that other Christians worship the devil.)

8. The book, trying to show a false prediction, quotes Heber C. Kimball as saying that he and other Mormons then living would go back to Missouri (228:1-10).

Ellipses are used to create one quotation that comes from two speeches, from two volumes, 325 pages apart. In one of the talks only a few lines away, Heber C. Kimball also said, "If we do not receive these things, it is because we do not live for them," making the prediction conditional on the worthiness of the Saints.

9. Several strange demonic experiences are quoted out of context by the authors who add, "Here again we have an obviously evil manifestation" to show that Mormonism is satanic (108:30).

Reading the full account, one finds that Joseph Smith instructed Lyman Wight "to chase Satan out," and in a second instance Joseph Smith "commanded Satan to leave." These were examples of casting out evil spirits and not of engaging in satanic practices as the book alleges.

Return to Table of Contents

 

 

FAIR is not owned, controlled by or affiliated with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. All research and opinions provided on this site are the sole responsibility of FAIR, and should not be interpreted as official statements of LDS doctrine, belief or practice.

If you like what FAIR does and you agree with our mission, we invite you to support FAIR in any way you are able. You can make a donation, or visit our Membership page for additional support ideas. FAIR only succeeds through the efforts of our gracious volunteers.

 

Welcome | Topical Guide | FAIR Publications | Join & Support FAIR | Message Boards
FAIR LDS Bookstore | News | FAIR Links | Contact FAIR | Home

Last Updated June 12, 2006
Copyright © 2007 by The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research. All Rights Reserved.
No portion of this site may be reproduced on any other Web site or in any other print publication
without the express written consent of FAIR. You may freely link to this information, however, or you
may print out copies to give to others, provided this copyright notice is included in your printout.

You can send comments/suggestions using our contact page.